Mali: Country Report | 2024
AI Generated Analysis based on UNHCR Forced Displacement Statisitics.
Executive Summary
Key Trends: Mali and the Central Sahel Displacement Crisis
A deepening crisis of internal displacement now defines the humanitarian emergency in Mali, creating a landscape of unprecedented need and regional instability. The number of people requiring our protection has swelled to nearly 500,000, driven by an alarming surge in internal conflict. The most critical development is the 19 per cent increase in Internally Displaced Persons (IDPs) in early 2024 alone, who now constitute nearly three-quarters of the entire displaced population. Behind this number is a story of acute vulnerability, with women and children disproportionately affected, underscoring the urgent need for targeted protection, health, and education services.
The geography of this crisis reveals an interlocking emergency that blurs the lines between source, transit, and host countries across the Central Sahel. While grappling with its own internal turmoil of over 400,000 IDPs, Mali continues to provide asylum to over 93,000 refugees, the vast majority from a single neighboring state. Simultaneously, Malian nationals seeking safety abroad place immense and disproportionate pressure on the generosity of host communities in a few neighboring countries. This volatility is compounded by a stark global protection gap: a Malian’s chance of receiving refugee status can vary from over 80 per cent in one host country to less than 1 per cent in another, making access to safety a matter of geography, not just need.
While pathways to solutions exist, they are being overwhelmed by the scale of new displacement. Although over 51,000 people have returned home, these gains are fragile and are now being reversed. The gap between those newly forced to flee and the availability of durable solutions like resettlement or local integration is widening at a distressing rate. The progress made in recent years is under direct threat, demonstrating that without a concerted effort to restore security and stability, humanitarian needs will continue to outpace our collective capacity to respond. Sustained international support is not just a request; it is the only viable path to prevent a generational catastrophe in the heart of the Sahel.
Population Overview
Population Overview: The Deepening Internal Displacement Crisis in Mali
The scale of forced displacement in Mali is characterized by a profound and escalating internal crisis. The data reveals that Internally Displaced Persons (IDPs) constitute the overwhelming majority of the population of concern, accounting for approximately 73 per cent of the nearly 500,000 individuals in need of protection. This long-standing trend has shown a worrying acceleration. The most significant development is the sharp increase in internal displacement, which rose by 69,090 people—a 19 per cent rise—between the end of 2023 and early 2024. This increase, driven almost exclusively by new internal movements, points to a deteriorating security situation and ongoing conflict within the country’s borders, eclipsing all other population changes.
Behind these stark numbers lies a demographic profile of significant vulnerability. The displaced population is overwhelmingly young, with a wide base in the population pyramid indicating a high youth dependency ratio. A pronounced gender imbalance is evident among adults, where women aged 18-59 comprise 27 per cent of the total displaced population, compared to just 17 per cent for men in the same age group. This demographic structure underscores acute protection risks and highlights critical needs for child protection, education, maternal healthcare, and targeted livelihood support for what are likely a high number of female-headed households.
While the internal crisis dominates the humanitarian landscape, Mali also hosts a significant refugee population. However, the refugee situation is highly concentrated, with individuals from one neighbouring country accounting for the vast majority of the over 93,000 refugees in Mali. Other nationalities form much smaller communities, requiring a tailored and diverse response.
Amidst the growing displacement, some movements toward solutions are visible, with over 51,000 former IDPs having returned to their areas of origin. However, these gains are dwarfed by the sheer volume of new displacement. The data from recent years confirms a persistent and worsening trend where internal displacement remains the primary and most urgent humanitarian challenge in Mali.
Demographics
AI Insight: Treemap of the Population of Concern in Mali by type, where Internally Displaced Persons constitute the vast majority of the 496,000 individuals., This treemap provides a breakdown of the 496,000 individuals classified as ‘Population of Concern’ in Mali as of 2024. The area of each rectangle is proportional to the size of the population group it represents.
The data highlights a significant internal displacement crisis, with Internally Displaced Persons (IDPs) being the largest group by a substantial margin, numbering 360,591, which is approximately 73% of the total.
The second-largest category is Returned IDPs, with 51,546 individuals. This suggests that while displacement is ongoing, some individuals have been able to return to their homes.
Other, much smaller, populations of concern are also represented, including 16 Returned Refugees. The remaining individuals are distributed across four other distinct categories, such as refugees, asylum-seekers, and others of concern, which together make up a smaller fraction of the total. The visualization underscores that internal displacement is the primary humanitarian challenge in Mali.
AI Insight: Population pyramid of displaced persons in Mali by age and gender, showing a very young population with a significantly higher proportion of adult women than adult men., This population pyramid illustrates the age and gender distribution of 2,207,379 displaced persons (including refugees, asylum-seekers, and IDPs) in Mali as of 2024. The chart is broken down into five-year age groups on the vertical axis and the percentage of the population on the horizontal axis, with males on the left and females on the right.
The pyramid has a wide base, indicating a very youthful population structure. The largest single demographic group is adult females aged 18-59, who constitute 27.2% of the total population. In contrast, males in the same age bracket make up a significantly smaller portion at 17.0%.
Children represent a substantial part of the population. The 0-4 age group consists of 13.4% females and 13.1% males. The gender distribution is nearly balanced across all child and adolescent age groups (0-17).
The elderly population (60+) is the smallest cohort, comprising 2.7% females and 2.4% males.
Overall, the data highlights two key features: a large youth dependency ratio and a pronounced gender imbalance among adults, with a surplus of women. This demographic profile suggests critical needs in areas such as child protection, education, maternal health, and targeted livelihood support for female-headed households.
Trends Over Time
AI Insight: Grouped column chart of population types in Mali from 2019 to 2024, where Internally Displaced Persons (IDPs) consistently constitute the vast majority of the population of concern., This grouped column chart presents the number of people (in thousands) for six different population types in Mali, with data provided for each year from 2019 to 2024. The population types include Internally Displaced Persons (IDPs), Returned IDPs, Returned Refugees, Asylum-seekers, Stateless Persons, and Others of Concern.
A statistical analysis reveals a significant disparity between the population groups. The data is heavily skewed, with a mean value of approximately 66,000 people but a median of only 136. This indicates that one category has exceptionally high numbers compared to the others. The maximum value recorded for a single group in a year is 379,932.
The dominant trend visible in the chart is the overwhelming prevalence of Internally Displaced Persons (IDPs), which constitute the largest group by a substantial margin in every year shown. Returned IDPs form the second-largest group, with figures ranging from approximately 20,000 to 80,000. All other categories, including Returned Refugees and Asylum-seekers, are numerically much smaller, often by several orders of magnitude. The chart effectively highlights that internal displacement is the most significant humanitarian concern in Mali during this period.
AI Insight: Horizontal bar chart of population changes in Mali between 2023 and 2024, where Internally Displaced Persons (IDPs) increased by nearly 70,000, while refugee and asylum-seeker populations saw slight decreases., This horizontal bar chart details the changes in six distinct population groups of concern to UNHCR in Mali, comparing figures from the end of 2023 to the beginning of 2024. The bars represent the absolute change in the number of people, with text labels providing both the absolute number and the percentage change for each group.
The most significant trend is the substantial increase in the number of Internally Displaced Persons (IDPs), which rose by 69,090 people (+19%). This single group accounts for the vast majority of the overall population change, reflecting a deteriorating security situation and ongoing displacement within Mali.
In contrast, other population groups experienced much smaller changes. The ‘Others of concern’ category saw a moderate increase of 5,489 people (+11%). Both refugee and asylum-seeker populations recorded slight decreases, with refugees declining by 110 individuals (-0.2%) and asylum-seekers by 295 individuals (-31%). The populations of both former refugee and former IDP returnees remained relatively stable with minor increases.
Overall, the data indicates a net increase in the total population of concern in Mali between the two periods, driven almost exclusively by the sharp rise in internal displacement. This highlights the escalating humanitarian crisis within the country’s borders.
AI Insight: Horizontal bar chart of the number of refugees in Mali by top 9 countries of origin for 2024, where the population is dominated by a single country of origin, with significantly fewer refugees from all other nations., This horizontal bar chart displays the distribution of refugee populations in Mali by their top nine countries of origin, plus an ‘Others’ category, as of 2024. The vertical axis lists the countries of origin, while the horizontal axis quantifies the number of individuals.
The data shows a highly skewed distribution. One country of origin accounts for the vast majority of refugees, with a population of 93,445. The remaining groups are substantially smaller, with the next largest group numbering 11,604. The smallest registered group consists of only 27 individuals.
Statistically, the mean number of refugees per origin category is 13,553, but this figure is heavily influenced by the largest group. A more representative measure for the smaller national groups is the median, which is 186 people. The large difference between the mean and the median, along with a high standard deviation of 29,355, underscores the extreme variability and the presence of a significant outlier in the dataset. This distribution indicates that while one nationality forms the primary focus for refugee response in Mali, a diverse range of smaller refugee populations with distinct needs also requires attention.
Geography & Movements
Geography of Displacement: Interlocking Crises in the Central Sahel
The geography of displacement related to Mali paints a picture of a deeply interconnected and rapidly escalating regional crisis. The data reveals that the country is simultaneously a major source of displacement, a significant host of refugees, and the site of a severe internal displacement crisis, reflecting the interlocking nature of instability across the Central Sahel.
The most alarming trend is the exponential growth of internal displacement within Mali’s own borders. Between 2019 and 2025, the number of internally displaced Malians has swelled to over 400,000, a figure that now dwarfs all other displaced populations in the country. This sharp increase points to a severe intensification of internal conflict and insecurity, which serves as the primary driver of new movements.
Behind these stark numbers of internal turmoil lies a story of regional spillover. The overwhelming majority of those forced to flee Mali seek safety in a handful of neighboring countries. This constitutes a pattern of highly concentrated displacement, placing immense pressure on the generosity of host communities. The data reveals a particularly disproportionate burden, with one country, Côte d’Ivoire, hosting over 3.2 million forcibly displaced people from Mali. This is more than thirteen times the number hosted by the next largest receiving country, illustrating the acute strain placed on a single nation.
At the same time, Mali continues to provide asylum, though its refugee population is also defined by a concentrated crisis. The data shows that refugees from just one neighboring country account for over 93,000 individuals, making up the vast majority of all refugees in Mali. This reciprocal displacement, compounded by growing inflows from countries like Burkina Faso, underscores that the lines between source, transit, and host countries in the Sahel are increasingly blurred. Taken together, these movements highlight an urgent need for comprehensive regional solutions and robust international support for host communities bearing the greatest responsibility.
AI Insight: Choropleth map of the number of displaced people from Mali by destination country in 2024, where the vast majority are hosted in a few neighboring West African nations., This world map visualizes the distribution of refugees, asylum-seekers, and other people of concern originating from Mali across 60 destination countries as of 2024. The map uses a color scale to represent the number of displaced persons in each country, revealing a pattern of displacement that is heavily concentrated in Mali’s immediate geographical region.
Statistical analysis of the underlying data shows an extremely skewed distribution. The number of displaced Malians per country ranges from as few as 5 to a maximum of 360,591 in a single host nation. The median number of individuals hosted is only 27, which contrasts sharply with the mean of approximately 12,000. This large difference indicates that a few countries host exceptionally large populations, pulling the average up. Furthermore, 75% of host countries shelter fewer than 195 individuals each.
This pattern underscores that the Malian displacement crisis is predominantly a regional one. The immense pressure of hosting is borne by a small number of neighboring countries, a common feature of forced displacement in the Sahel where populations seek safety across the nearest borders. The visualization effectively highlights the disproportionate responsibility shouldered by these nations and points to where humanitarian resources are most critically needed.
Origin of Displaced Populations
AI Insight: Horizontal bar chart of the top 9 countries of origin for refugees in Mali in 2024, where the refugee population is dominated by individuals from a single country, constituting the vast majority of the total., This horizontal bar chart details the origins of refugees residing in Mali as of 2024, ranking the top nine countries and an ‘Other’ category by population size. The visualization highlights a stark concentration of refugees from one primary country of origin, which accounts for 93,445 individuals. This is in sharp contrast to the other source countries; the median refugee population from a single origin is only 186 people, and the minimum is 27. This heavily skewed distribution indicates that Mali’s refugee situation is predominantly defined by a single, large-scale crisis in a specific country, with much smaller refugee populations arriving from a variety of other nations.
AI Insight: Alluvial chart of the forcibly displaced population in Mali by country of origin from 2019 to 2025, where the number of internally displaced Malians has increased dramatically to become the vast majority of the total displaced population., This alluvial chart displays the evolution of forcibly displaced populations residing in Mali, categorized by their country of origin, for the years 2019 through 2025. The vertical axis represents the number of people in thousands. The data highlights a significant overall increase in the displaced population in Mali during this period.
The most striking trend is the exponential growth of Internally Displaced Persons (IDPs) from Mali itself. Starting as a significant but not dominant group in 2019, the Malian IDP population swells to over 400,000 by 2025, constituting the largest portion of the total displaced population by a wide margin. This indicates a severe escalation of internal conflict and insecurity within Mali.
Displaced populations from neighboring countries have also increased: - Burkina Faso: The population from Burkina Faso shows a steady and substantial increase, becoming the second-largest group of displaced people in Mali. - Mauritania and Niger: These populations also experience growth, but at a more modest rate compared to those from Mali and Burkina Faso. - Cote d’Ivoire: This group remains the smallest and is relatively stable throughout the period.
The visualization underscores a worsening humanitarian crisis in Mali, driven primarily by internal displacement, but also compounded by regional instability pushing people from neighboring Sahel countries to seek refuge.
Destination
AI Insight: Horizontal bar chart of the top 10 destination countries for forcibly displaced people from Mali as of 2024, where Côte d’Ivoire is the main destination, hosting over 3.2 million people, far exceeding all other countries., This chart details the top ten destination countries for people forcibly displaced from Mali as of 2024. The data shows a highly concentrated distribution, with one country hosting the vast majority. The total number of displaced people across these ten countries is approximately 5.17 million.
The specific numbers for each host country are as follows: - Côte d’Ivoire: 3,230,895 - Mauritania: 239,970 - Burkina Faso: 172,741 - Niger: 150,358 - Chad: 133,025 - France: 90,094 - Cameroon: 78,920 - Senegal: 32,581 - Guinea: 23,205 - Nigeria: 14,337
Statistical analysis reveals a significant outlier. Côte d’Ivoire hosts approximately 62.5% of the total displaced population shown in this chart. The number of people it hosts is more than 13 times that of the second-highest country, Mauritania. This highlights a critical humanitarian situation concentrated in a single neighboring country, while other regional nations and France host considerably smaller, yet still significant, populations.
Asylum System
The immense pressure on national asylum systems worldwide is reflected in the dual role played by countries such as Mali, which is both a significant host country and a major country of origin for refugees. The data reveals that in 2024 alone, authorities in Mali rendered 18,601 refugee status determination decisions for individuals seeking safety within its borders. A substantial number—over 8,500—were granted refugee status at the first instance, demonstrating a functioning protection framework.
However, behind these positive outcomes lies a system under considerable strain. The volatility in asylum applications to Mali over the past five years, coupled with a widening gap between new claims and decisions rendered, points to a growing backlog. This constitutes a significant challenge, lengthening the period of uncertainty for those awaiting a decision on their future. Furthermore, protection outcomes within Mali vary starkly by nationality, with recognition rates in 2024 ranging from as low as 7 per cent to as high as 100 per cent for certain groups, reflecting the shifting dynamics of regional conflicts.
At the same time, Malian nationals continued to seek international protection abroad, facing highly divergent outcomes. An analysis of the top 10 host countries by decision volume shows a critical disparity in protection. The refugee recognition rate for Malians ranged from over 82 per cent in one country to less than 1 per cent in another. For many, complementary forms of protection proved a vital, though inconsistent, safeguard. This divergence underscores a persistent global challenge: access to international protection often depends not only on the merits of a claim but on the jurisdiction in which it is lodged.
AI Insight: Bar chart of asylum applications and decisions in Mali from 2019 to 2024, where the number of cases fluctuated significantly, with a peak of 658 cases in one instance., This bar chart presents statistics on asylum applications and decisions for Malian nationals over a six-year period from 2019 to 2024. The data is categorized into different asylum stages across these years. Statistically, the number of cases per category varies widely, from a minimum of 10 to a maximum of 658. The average number of cases across all categories and years is approximately 152. The distribution of data is right-skewed, with a median of 108, indicating that most data points are concentrated at lower values, but there are instances of exceptionally high numbers that pull the average up. The subtitle notes that one person may have more than one application, which is an important consideration when interpreting the total application figures. The overall trend suggests significant volatility in asylum-seeking and processing for Malians during this period.
AI Insight: Alluvial diagram of Refugee Status Determination decisions for Mali in 2024, where the majority of the 18,601 decisions are made at the first instance level, leading primarily to refugee status recognition., This alluvial diagram visualizes the flow and outcomes of 18,601 Refugee Status Determination (RSD) decisions concerning individuals from Mali recorded in 2024. The chart is structured into vertical axes representing different stages or classifications of the decision-making process, such as the decision level (e.g., First instance, Appeal) and the final outcome (e.g., Recognized, Rejected, Otherwise closed).
The width of the flows, or ribbons, connecting these axes is proportional to the number of decisions. The diagram illustrates the primary pathways applicants take through the asylum system.
Key statistical observations include: - Total Decisions: The visualization accounts for a total of 18,601 decisions. - Dominant Pathway: The largest flow in the dataset consists of 8,529 decisions, indicating a primary outcome that affects a substantial portion of the applicants. This flow originates at the ‘First instance’ level and terminates at ‘Recognized’, signifying that the most common outcome is the granting of refugee status without an appeal. - Data Skewness: The decision counts are highly skewed. While the largest single flow is 8,529, the median flow size is only 70.5, which suggests that many pathways in the determination process, such as appeals or specific sub-types of closure, involve a much smaller number of individuals. - Process Flow: The chart effectively demonstrates how the initial pool of applicants is distributed through various outcomes. A significant number of decisions are finalized at the first instance, while smaller flows branch off to represent cases that are rejected and subsequently appealed, or are closed for other administrative reasons. The visualization provides a clear quantitative overview of the asylum process’s efficiency and outcomes for this specific population and period.
AI Insight: Area chart of cumulative asylum applications versus decisions in Mali from 2020 to 2024, where the widening gap between the two lines indicates a growing backlog of pending cases and increased processing times., This area chart displays the cumulative number of asylum applications compared to the cumulative number of first-instance decisions issued in Mali for the period 2020 to 2024. The vertical axis represents the cumulative total, while the horizontal axis marks the years.
The upper line of the chart tracks the total number of applications received, and the lower line tracks the total number of decisions made. Both lines show a steady upward trend, indicating a continuous flow of new asylum applications and ongoing processing by authorities.
The key feature of the visualization is the shaded area between these two lines, which represents the ‘gap’—the number of cases registered but still awaiting a first-instance decision. This gap has visibly widened over the five-year period, signifying that the rate of new applications has outpaced the rate of decisions. This growing backlog directly translates to longer average processing times for asylum seekers, a key metric highlighted in the chart’s subtitle.
Recognition Rates
AI Insight: Vertical bar chart of the Refugee Recognition Rate by the top 10 countries of origin in Mali for 2024, where rates vary significantly from a low of 7% to a high of 100%., This vertical bar chart displays the refugee recognition rates in Mali during 2024 for asylum seekers from the top 10 countries of origin. The countries are ordered based on the total number of decisions made, not the recognition rate itself.
The data covers 10 nationalities with a total number of decisions ranging from 128 to 8,534. The key variable, the Refugee Recognition Rate, shows substantial variation. The average recognition rate across these groups is 52.8%, with a median of 44.9%. The rates span a wide spectrum, with the lowest being 7.03% and the highest reaching 100%, indicating that all applicants from at least one country of origin were granted refugee status. The data also specifies that no individuals received complementary protection, making the Refugee Recognition Rate and the Total Recognition Rate identical. This visualization underscores the disparity in asylum outcomes in Mali based on the applicant’s country of origin.
AI Insight: Bar chart of the Refugee Recognition Rate for Malian nationals in 2024, where rates across the top 10 countries of asylum by decision volume vary widely, from a high of 83% to a low of less than 1%., This bar chart displays the 2024 refugee recognition rates for asylum seekers from Mali in the 10 countries with the highest number of total decisions. The data highlights a significant disparity in protection outcomes depending on the country of asylum.
Statistically, the refugee recognition rate (the proportion of positive decisions for refugee status) shows extreme variation. The mean rate across these 10 countries is 14.8%, but the median is only 3.8%. This discrepancy indicates that a few countries have significantly higher recognition rates, which pull the average up, while half of the countries have rates below 4%. The rates range from a maximum of 82.9% down to a minimum of 0%.
When considering the Total Recognition Rate, which includes both refugee status and complementary protection, the mean rises to 28.4% with a median of 16.5%. This suggests that complementary protection is a significant pathway to safety for Malians in some countries. The total number of decisions made in these countries ranges from 2,288 to 65,484. The chart is ordered by this total volume, not by the recognition rate, meaning that some countries with low rates may process a very high number of cases. The analysis reveals a critical protection gap, where the likelihood of a Malian national being granted international protection is heavily dependent on the asylum country in which they apply.
Solutions
Solutions for the Forcibly Displaced
The path towards durable solutions for those forcibly displaced from Mali has been marked by significant volatility, reflecting the complex and shifting security and political landscape in the central Sahel. While progress has been made in certain periods, the data reveals the fragility of these gains and the persistent gap between needs and available pathways to a stable future.
Behind the stark numbers of displacement, there have been notable efforts to find lasting solutions. The overall number of Malians who found a durable solution, such as voluntary repatriation or local integration, peaked in 2023 at nearly 79,800. This followed a period of strong momentum, with substantial numbers also recorded in 2021 and 2022. This progress highlights the impact that concerted efforts and windows of opportunity can have. However, the gains are not always linear; by mid-2024, the number of solutions had decreased to approximately 51,500, a reminder of how quickly conditions on the ground can affect the viability of return or integration.
A more granular analysis of the relationship between newly recognized refugees and the solutions available to them reveals a precarious dynamic. In some years, such as 2022, the number of solutions offered outpaced the number of newly recognized Malian refugees, indicating a capacity to address immediate needs. In other years, the opposite was true. The data for 2024 shows a particularly concerning trend, with new refugee recognitions sharply increasing to 83 while available solutions fell to just 16. This growing deficit underscores the challenge of keeping pace with new displacement even as efforts continue to resolve protracted situations.
This volatility demonstrates that progress on solutions is inextricably linked to stability and security in areas of origin. While large-scale return and integration programmes can achieve significant results when conditions are favourable, the capacity to provide timely and sustainable solutions remains under constant threat from renewed conflict and instability. Sustained political will and investment are essential to ensure that opportunities for solutions are not just temporary, but form the foundation of lasting peace for displaced Malians.
AI Insight: Column chart of durable solutions for forcibly displaced people from Mali from 2019 to 2024, where the number of solutions peaked in 2023 at nearly 80,000 before decreasing in 2024., This column chart illustrates the annual total number of durable solutions for forcibly displaced people from Mali who have crossed international borders, for the years 2019 through 2024. The data shows significant fluctuation over the period.
In 2019, the total number of solutions was approximately 35,100. This figure dropped to about 20,500 in 2020. A substantial increase occurred in 2021, with the count rising to nearly 77,000. In 2022, there was a slight decrease to approximately 64,600 solutions. The highest point in the period was reached in 2023, with a peak of nearly 79,800 solutions. The most recent data for 2024 indicates a drop to approximately 51,500 solutions.
The statistical profile reveals that the data for each year is highly skewed, with the mean being significantly lower than the maximum value. This suggests that one or a few types of solutions likely account for the vast majority of the total count each year. The overall trend highlights a volatile period, with a notable surge in solutions from 2021 to 2023, which may correspond to specific large-scale return or integration programs.
AI Insight: Dual line and ribbon chart of refugee recognitions versus available solutions in Mali from 2019 to 2024, where the gap between new recognitions and solutions has fluctuated significantly each year., This chart compares the annual number of new refugee recognitions with the number of durable solutions available for refugees from Mali for the period 2019 to 2024. Two lines represent ‘recognitions’ (blue) and ‘solutions’ (teal), and the shaded area between them highlights the gap.
The data shows a highly volatile relationship between the two metrics: - In 2019, solutions (274) exceeded recognitions (168). - In 2020, recognitions (77) outpaced solutions (32). - In 2021, solutions (214) were again higher than recognitions (169). - In 2022, the largest surplus of solutions was recorded, with 329 solutions against 95 recognitions. - In 2023, both figures dropped to their lowest point in the period, with 12 solutions and 10 recognitions. - In 2024, the trend reversed sharply, with 83 recognitions compared to only 16 solutions.
Overall, the chart demonstrates that there is no consistent trend; in some years, the number of solutions provided was sufficient to cover newly recognized refugees, while in others, a significant deficit occurred, increasing the population in need of a solution. The footnotes ‘a’ and ‘b’ in the title provide specific definitions for ‘refugee recognitions’ and ‘solutions’.